In 2013, Lori Loughlin played Jennifer Shannon in the movie adaptation of Suzi Weinert’s novel, Garage Sale Stalker, titled Garage Sale Mystery. In this film, Loughlin portrays the owner of an antiques store who, in addition to her business, solves murders.
The success of Garage Sale Mystery among audiences sparked the creation of more films in the series. Over the following six years, the movies garnered a huge fan base and featured Lori Laughlin in each movie, along with the cast of Steve Bacic, Sarah Strange, Eva Bourne, Connor Stanhope and Kevin O’Grady.
If you’d like to watch all 16 Garage Sale Mystery movies in chronological order from start to finish, here’s a list for you: these films aired between 2013 and 2019.
- Garage Sale Mystery (2013)
- All That Glitters (2014)
- The Deadly Room (2015)
- The Wedding Dress (2015)
- Guilty Until Proven Innocent (2016)
- The Novel Murders (2016)
- The Art or Murder (2017)
- The Beach Murder (2017)
- Murder By Text (2017)
- Murder Most Medieval (2017)
- A Case of Murder (2017)
- The Pandora’s Box Murders (2018)
- The Mask Murder (2018)
- Picture a Murder (2018)
- Murder in D Minor (2018)
- Search & Seized (2019)
The Garage Sale Mystery series concluded in 2019 with Search & Seized, contrary to initial expectations that a 17th movie, Three Little Murders, would be released that same year. As highlighted above, this would have been the final movie of the series.
In 2019, Lori Loughlin, the lead actress of Three Little Murders, was arrested in connection to the College Admissions Bribery Scandal. Hallmark quickly severed ties with her due to the negative press and impending investigation, resulting in the cancellation of the series.
Although most of the movie had been filmed, the production was not completed and the movie never aired. Consequently, there are only 16 movies in the series, despite the possibility of more.